Warren Feeney – 16 January, 2013
Parekowhai's two bronze bulls atop pianos placed among the ruin of the inner city made absolute sense as a metaphor for nature run rampant. On First Looking..gave expression to something about Christchurch that words had previously failed to encompass. It connected with the local community in a way that it is difficult to find a comparable precedent for in Christchurch's history.
Christchurch in retrospect
In Christchurch in 2012 it often seemed as though the arts were everywhere - except in the spaces of an art gallery; on the walls of buildings, in temporary make-shift spaces (reconstructed offices and houses), on sites recently demolished and cleared of rubble, online, as giveaway brochures, in the windows of heritage buildings about to be knocked down and on the streets of the inner city.
The positives were that in spite of the continued absence of a more familiar arts infrastructure, necessity did prove to be the mother of invention. New opportunities were revealed for exhibitions and installations, allowing the arts to assume a welcome visibility beyond the white cube of the gallery space in a city that, for most of its history, has demonstrated little tolerance for art in public spaces. The downside was an uncomfortable degree of uncertainty as temporary - and what were often assumed to be permanent venues and projects - came and went. In 2013, no one should underestimate the ongoing fallout from the lack of spaces and venues in Christchurch. Immediately apparent in the demands for accommodation throughout the city, this also continues to represent a serious challenge for all involved in the arts, but particularly artists facing a shortage of studio and gallery spaces.
In 2012, artist-run space, ABC Gallery on Lincoln Road was the first victim. Established in 2011 by Matt Akehurst, Zhonghao Chen, Oscar Enberg and Sebastian Warne, ABC’s galleries and studios closed in February. A change in ownership saw the demolition of the building and the development of more offices and café culture in Addington. Its absence was felt immediately, not least because the gallery closed, but also due to the departure from Christchurch of a number of the artists in its studios.
Its closure made the opening in June of the artists’ project space, Dog Park, and the support that accompanied it from Creative New Zealand, all the more welcome. Established by curator Chloe Geoghegan with Ella Sutherland, and later joined by lecturer in Art History at the University of Canterbury, Dr. Barbara Garrie, it has embraced the fine arts in the broadest sense, including an interactive editing and publishing of Matt Galloway’s The Silver Bulletin, in an edition conceived and realised in the gallery in early August.
Dog Park signified one further example of the commitment that Creative New Zealand has made since 22 February 2011 to ensure that an arts infrastructure is nurtured, artists remain in Christchurch and that the contribution that the city makes to the arts continues to exist. As the target of misguided criticisms following the February earthquake, CNZ’s advocacy and contribution has made a difference. To date, CNZ has contributed $1.9 million towards a range of projects; relocating artists into studio spaces, supporting new initiatives like Dog Park, Art Box, the Christchurch Art Gallery’s Outer Spaces projects, Gapfiller and much more.
Throughout the year, Jonathan Smart Gallery again operated a business-as-usual model with a programme of sustained quality. Looking at the line up of exhibitions in his temporary gallery space in sculptor Neil Dawson’s studio in Linwood, (for example; Saskia Leek, John Pule, Heather Straka, Lonnie Hutchinson and Miranda Parkes), the Jonathan Smart Gallery, all too modestly worked on the premise that exhibitions would be curated and take place regardless of circumstances. Smart opened the year with Dense Hang, a group show that established a context for the programme to follow. Work by artists such as Peter Wheeler, Fiona Pardington, Stephen Bambury and Rob Hood genuinely surprised, introducing the gallery visitor to little known or new aspects of each artist’s practice.
There was however, no contest for the highlight of 2012. It was Michael Parekowhai‘s On First looking into Chapman’s Homer from the Christchurch Art Gallery’s Outer Spaces programme. Located in temporary premises upstairs at 212 Madras Street and on an adjacent vacant site across the road, On First Looking into Chapman’s Homer, returned from the Venice Biennale, opening in late June and establishing an unexpectedly powerful and relevant - yet also entirely romantic - relationship with the public. The two bronze bulls atop pianos (Chapman’s Homer, and A Peak in Darien) placed among the ruin of the inner city made absolute sense as a metaphor for nature run rampant. On First Looking gave expression to something about Christchurch that words had previously failed to encompass. It may have simply been the place and time, but it connected with the local community in a way that it is difficult to find a comparable precedent for in Christchurch’s history.
The Christchurch Art Gallery’s Outer Spaces programme was equally welcome because gallery staff acknowledged that the city was now a different place. Sadly, the public gallery was going to be closed for some time. Changing shows every four weeks in the Madras Street space - this must be unheard of for any New Zealand public gallery - Outer Spaces set a precedent that it would be great to see continue when Montreal Street finally reopens.
Outer Spaces featured a number of exhibitions that also worked because of the way in which this temporary space was continually transformed. In August, a group show, Out of Place, presented works by Katherine Jaeger, Chris Pole, Tim J. Veling and Charlotte Watson. All considered the constructed environment anew. Watson’s reconfiguration of the office space used by gallery staff was particularly impressive. Acting as installation, environment and sculpture, she assembled erroneous shelfing, tables and chairs that brought to life the spatial complexities and contradictions of an analytical cubist painting.
The question mark in the title of Scott Flanagan‘s Do You Remember me Like I Do? in September was particularly pertinent. Gathering black video tape like a lake in the middle of the room, it implied that it might be alluding to the presence of memories. Yet Flanagan’s installation transcended the premise that this was simply a work about personal loss. Haunting in its impact, the gallery visitor found themselves looking into a void, uncomfortably aware that there was nothing staring back.
Of course, Outer Spaces also had another life as public art works. The most successful remains Wayne Youle’s I Seem to Have Temporarily Lost my Sense of Humour. Completed in December 2011, this large-scale public mural on the corner of Colombo and Byron Streets remains animated and engaging each time it is seen. Other large-scale works on walls varied more in their ability to connect with community. Kay Rosen’s Here are the People and There is the Steeple works best as a large and attractive wall of geometric yellow and black shapes, bringing spirit and energy to a vacant grey site visible from Durham Street. Yet, it also seems like it is sharing a private joke in public in an uncomfortable way that too willingly paraded its punch line.
Also currently vying for attention is Ash Keating’s Concrete Propositions, a massive work of art that must occupy half of the space between Gloucester and Worcester Streets. Firing paint onto a concrete wall, Keating has assembled a spattered and dribbled Jackson-Pollock-abstract-expressionist mural that up close is an object of great energy and beauty. Yet the experience is also one that may have been more suitably viewed in an art gallery space. Viewed from a distance Concrete Propositions was up against some serious competition from the surrounding demolition site: The adjacent building with earthquake damage cracks across its entire surface, plus the uninterrupted view from Madras to Manchester Street.
Making the most of the city as demolition site, and anticipating the possibilities for the arts in such circumstances, Measure the City with the Body, curated by the former director of The Physics Room Stephen Cleland, was an appropriate choice for its temporary site in Sydenham. Featuring video and film of performance and installations by Claire Fontaine, Daniel Malone, Junebum Park, Mark Wallinger, Pak Sheung Chuen, William Hsu and Yuk King Tan, it was a project that drew attention to the potential of the arts to engage with the public beyond the gallery. Even the placement of temporary sites on vacant spaces close to The Physics Room seemed to be in on the act. Using a series of freight containers as galleries for video works, the visitor’s attention was captured and sustained until they stepped back outside on to the empty sites, each time confronted with the context in which this programme offered new possibilities for the experience of art.
Artworks installed by SCAPE’s public art programme in December appear as though they have taken up the spirit of Cleland’s challenge. Both Joanna Langford‘s The High Country and Mexican artist Héctor Zamora’s Muegano are large works that possess a welcome and visible public presence. Both should have been part of the SCAPE’s 6th biennial project, yet their current exhibition in the city is no less impressive, with or without the wider context of a bi-annual arts event. Langford’s The High Country is sited 10 metres above ground on the corner of Montreal and Kilmore Streets. Constructed from recycled materials it appears like an apologetic utopian city - has Langford ever conceived and realised such a mature, entertaining or intelligent work? Lit up day and night it looks like an unused prop from a 1930s Sci-fi movie like H G. Wells’ The Shape of Things To Come. However, its humour and location opposite the now-demolished Cramner Courts also offers warm and poignant commentary on the folly of the ambitions of human behaviour.
In 2012, Director of The National, Caroline Billing offered an exhibition programme in which objects and ideas seemed perfectly integrated. In February, The National presented The Possession Obsession of Cocoa Vitako, new works by jeweller Octavia Cook, exhibiting under an anagram of her name in which her work become the subject of a show that critiqued its reason for being considered worthy of attention, alongside complementary images from pseudo-fashion magazines. Like the majority of exhibitions The National held, Possession Obsession represented a conversation with a known audience - those who admired, purchased and wore the objects on display - and it spoke to its fan-base in a disarmingly clever and unpretentious way.
The Ilam School of Fine Arts Gallery continued to make good use of one of the city’s best exhibition gallery spaces still intact and typically, exhibitions by Fatu Feu’u, Tony de Lautour and Select, works by graduates and post-graduates were all characterised by a restraint and elegance in installation. This worked particularly well for de Lautour’s exhibition early in 2012, in which he acknowledged the work of Kasimir Malevich and did so based on the premise that less was definitely more.
So does all this activity; exhibitions, installations and public art works seem like reassurance that the arts are in increasingly good heart in Christchurch? It would be misleading to entirely assume that this is the reality. The city continues to feel like two steps forward and one or more steps back. Just this week, I met with a local artist, four weeks away from leaving the city for better territory. She had already relocated twice since 22 February 2011 from a studio in the Arts Centre to rented accommodation she had converted into a studio, gallery and home, exhibiting her work and other artists on a regular basis. However, all has suddenly changed. Rapidly increasing rents, (flamed by insurance payouts for temporary accommodation to home owners needing short-term leases while their own home are repaired), now see her facing overheads that have put her out of her premises and business. She leaves after more than 20 years of working as a professional artist in Christchurch.
Adapting to changing circumstances and recognising that the temporary or transitional has its own distinct merits and rewards are concepts worth holding on to and cultivating in Christchurch. The Social, a public arts programme of interventions, temporary and transitional sculpture, performance and installation, instigated by the University of Canterbury School of Fine Arts technician and artist Gaby Montejo has sought to make a virtue of such circumstances. Coordinated by artist Lucy Matthews, The Social consists of proposals from local artists, implemented from November and run on a weekly basis until the end of February 2013 in the ReStart retail precinct in Cashel Street. Often seeking community participation, it has included projects like The Loss Adjustors, curated by Blue Oyster director, Jamie Hanton and Alex Lovell-Smith. The Loss Adjustors satirised the EQC claims process, offering those making a claim the appropriate form transformed into a work of art. Set up within 2½ months, The Social acts as a model for future transitional arts projects; initiated by artists, artworks and performances that take place outside familiar venues, a reconsideration of how the arts connects with communities and increased public visibility and participation in the arts by the wider community.
The Social also side-steps the premise of the arts talking exclusively to an arts-literate audience. At last, an arts initiative for Christchurch that it is possible to claim represents an appropriate way forward for the foreseeable future and whose potential has only just begun to surface. The Social is an arts project that is as affirmative for the artists participating as it is for arts audiences and the wider community. It represents the kind of democratic shift in normalising a community’s experiencing of the arts that I would trust Christchurch will remain keen to retain. In doing so, it will be a unique public arts project in the city’s history; one that is embraced as being important to the wellbeing of all its residents well into the future.
Comprehensive online access to contemporary art & leading galleries around the world
Two Rooms presents a program of residencies and projects
by leading international and New Zealand contemporary artists.
Love to hear orchestral classical music live?
CLICK HERE to follow this orchestra’s adventurous performing programme
To read a transcript of the panel discussion “Whose Oceania?” held recently in London, and more on NZ arts abroad, CLICK HERE