Warren Feeney – 23 December, 2010
While the Wellington City Gallery's recent survey show of up and coming artists, 'Ready to Roll' seemed deliberately loud and attention seeking, spreading throughout both floors of the gallery like a series of compact solo exhibitions, 'Uncanny Valley' is restrained, concise and measured with a clear priority to place images in conversation with one another and it works best when considered as a whole, greater than the sum of its parts.
Cat Auburn, Marie-Claire Brehaut, ZhongHao Chen, Arie Hellendoorn, Rosa Scott, Roberta Thornley, Shannon Williamson
Curated by Jennifer Hay
19 November 2010 - 27 February 2011
Modest in scale but impressive in the visual and thematic relationships that it establishes between the works of the seven participating artists, Uncanny Valley is a rare achievement for a survey exhibition of contemporary art. This is the Christchurch Art Gallery’s fifth show of emerging artists and, to its credit, all selected works by Cat Auburn, Marie-Claire Brehaut, ZhongHao Chen, Arie Hellendoorn, Rosa Scott, Roberta Thornley and Shannon Williamson all look as though they belong in the same gallery space together. Okay, it could be argued that the empathy between images might be because six of the seven participants share a commonality of materials as either works on paper or canvas, but there is a pervasive atmosphere of melancholy in Uncanny Valley that is almost tangible. While the Wellington City Gallery’s recent survey show of up and coming artists, Ready to Roll seemed deliberately loud and attention seeking, spreading throughout both floors of the gallery like a series of compact solo exhibitions, Uncanny Valley is restrained, concise and measured with a clear priority to place images in conversation with one another and it works best when considered as a whole, greater than the sum of its parts.
Roberta Thornley’s bittersweet portrait, Meme (Crying my mother’s tears), may be the key reason. It casts a haunting presence and severity that resonates throughout the entire gallery, influencing all within reach. If Arie Hellendoorn’s surreal and colourful Pop Art paintings, Portrait Woman and Portrait Man (both highlights of this exhibition) had been placed in a different group show alongside works by artists such as Sam Mitchell or Seung Yul Oh, Hellendoorn’s work could seem ironic and playful. In Uncanny Valley these twin portraits are decidedly uneasy, as though revealing a willing victim’s dispassionate extermination of self and identity. Similarly, the leftovers of the recently consumed feast in ZhongHai Chen’s Phobic Phobia might seem humorous and less like the evidence of the abandoned remnants of an addiction to anxious, compulsive behaviour.
Although Shannon Williamson’s work frequently conjure up associations with H. R. Giger and Alien Insurrections, her art remains too astute to be limited by any sources. These images are compelling in their ambiguity and impeccably crafted. They refuse to stay still, perpetually reinventing themselves between anxious nightmares and transparent, lyrical anatomical studies. In Rest Care, Cat Auburn’s life size, fibreglass sculptured pony, with its head tethered to a four poster bed works beautifully as a perverse and innocent ‘if only’ childhood wish, with the creature positioned uncomfortably in a place that it does not belong as a kind of curious, fretful symbol of humanity’s ambiguous relationship with nature.
Less convincing, but certainly not out of place, are contributions from Rosa Scott and Marie-Claire Brehaut. Scott’s paintings seem like transition pieces. The intimate scale of her previous paintings of domestic pets was near perfect but the expressionist, larger painterly intentions evident in Uncanny Valley are a reminder that sometimes less is genuinely more, and although Brehaut’s appropriation of family photographs may seem ideal for this exhibition, the literal association and treatment of her subjects with the show’s title tends to quickly close down the resonance and longevity of these paintings.
Indeed, if survey shows like Uncanny Valley have any overriding weakness, it resides in the use of thematic titles that too-readily limit the gallery visitor’s reading of the work. Although this exhibition comes close to being guilty of such charges, in this instance it succeeds because of the astute selection and grouping of images. Read the title, walk through the gallery and enjoy the otherness.
EyeContact hopes to be adding further visual documentation of this exhibition shortly.
From Where I Stand…: 12 Aug - 21 Oct
Benjamin Work: 12 Aug - 21 Oct
Hikalu Clarke: 12 Aug – 21 Oct
Two Rooms presents a program of residencies and projects
by leading international and New Zealand contemporary artists.
Comprehensive online access to contemporary art & leading galleries around the world
Love to hear orchestral classical music live?
CLICK HERE to follow this orchestra’s adventurous performing programme